Everything Vegan at Potbelly Sandwiches (2023)

Potbelly at a surface level seems slightly better than most sandwich shops, but not by much. But when you take a closer look, Potbelly is actually pretty dang great compared to other sandwich shops.

They may not have any vegan meat-substitutes such as tempeh or tofu, but they have numerous vegetables to put on a toasted loaf of bread, pretty good salads, as well as sometimes vegan soup and other goodies.

I’d say Potbelly is pretty good for a Vegan, at least if the Soup of the day is Vegan.

Which Sandwich Options are vegan at Potbelly?

  • Veggie Melt Sandwich (No Cheese)
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich (PB&J)
  • Mediterranean Sandwich (no chicken, no feta)

Make sure you order your sandwich on one of their vegan white bread’s (see below) rather than their multi-grain bread, as it contains honey and thus isn’t vegan.
I’d also highly recommend adding other vegetables to these sandwiches, as there’s plenty of vegan veggies to add, as well as condiments like hummus (see below for all those) that can really take your sandwich up a notch.

What about the salads?

  • Farmhouse Salad (no meat, no cheese, no egg, sub dressing)
  • Apple Walnut Salad (no meat, no cheese)
  • Powerhouse Salad (no meat, no egg)
  • Balsamic Vinaigrette
  • Non-Fat Vinaigrette
  • Potbelly Vinaigrette

Just like with the sandwich I’d recommend to add some vegetables to the above salads, or build your own if you want a salad composing of specific vegetables.

Vegan Side Dishes at Potbelly:

  • Garden Vegetable Soup (No Croutons) – See Below
  • Whole Pickle
  • Various Chip-Flavors

Sometimes they’ll also have Apple Sauce or another minor side dish, but they’re not available at every location so I didn’t list it above.

As for the chips at Potbelly’s, it varies based on location, so search up the brand of chips or check the back to see which are vegan. They’ll always have at least a couple vegan options when it comes to their chips though, so don’t worry about it till you’re there if you want some chips.

As for the Soups, Potbelly normally only has one or two soups at a time, both of which may not be Vegan, so don’t count on them to be there every time you go.

Is Potbelly bread vegan?

  • White Bread
  • “Skinny” White Bread
  • “Big” White Bread
  • All Bagels (varies by location) but the Cheddar-Herb Bagel

Potbelly’s only other bread (Whole-Grain) contains honey so it isn’t vegan, but it is dairy and egg-free.

Plant-based condiments

  • Hummus
  • Italian Seasoning
  • Mustard, Ketchup, and Other Basic Condiments
  • Olive Oil

I’d highly recommend the Hummus & Italian Seasoning if you’re getting a sandwich. They take Potbelly’s Sandwiches to a whole new level.

Salad Add-ins & Vegetables for Potbelly Sandwiches:

  • Artichoke Hearts
  • Cucumbers
  • Diced Apple
  • Dried Cranberries
  • Garbanzo Beans
  • Grape Tomatoes
  • Grapes
  • Hot Peppers
  • Lettuce
  • Mushrooms
  • Onion
  • Pickle
  • Red Onions
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Tomato

It should be free to add any of the above to your sandwich. As for salads it depends on the specific Potbelly, not all of them will let you have unlimited toppings for free in your Salad.

Cruelty Free Reviews

Cruelty Free Reviews

CrueltyFreeReviews serves as a digital guide and a handy manual for new vegans and experienced plant-based veterans alike. Founded back in 2018 by a group of plant-based enthusiasts, we are dedicated to a vegan lifestyle and animal rights. With our team having more than 10 years of plant-based guidance experience by now, we want to give back to the vegan community and support anyone on this journey.